Author: Dann Corbit
Date: 16:27:25 10/25/04
Go up one level in this thread
On October 24, 2004 at 16:53:41, martin fierz wrote: >On October 24, 2004 at 16:42:32, Dann Corbit wrote: > >>Not a lot of games so far, and at fast time control. >>AMD 2.2 GHz with 256 MB ram/engine on G/10+10 (ponder off): >> Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws >>1 Ruffian 1.0.5 : 2759 129 167 21 73.8 % 2579 23.8 % >>2 Delfi 4.5 CIPS : 2707 138 121 21 66.7 % 2587 38.1 % >>3 Pharaon v3.1 : 2646 153 128 21 57.1 % 2596 28.6 % >>4 Glc 3.034 : 2631 158 118 21 54.8 % 2598 33.3 % >>5 Muse0899 : 2631 158 118 21 54.8 % 2598 33.3 % >>6 AnMon_550 : 2558 163 153 21 42.9 % 2608 9.5 % >>7 Fafis v1.5 : 2463 149 132 21 28.6 % 2622 28.6 % >>8 Dragon46Wb : 2404 146 123 21 21.4 % 2630 33.3 % >> >>But a very impressive showing, none the less. >> >>The games so far: >>ftp://cap.connx.com/pub/chess-engines/new-approach/muscles.pgn.bz2 > >hi dann, > >nice to see that kind of subject header :-) >but i have tested muse much more thoroughly than you have, and can say with >certainty that it is NOT an elite engine. based on my results it should have a >WBEC rating of around 2420. however, i cannot resist posting a game that patrick >buchmann recorded during his test of muse... now that's what i call nice - not >just the result, but also because it really played a nice game! > >the bottom line: muse sometimes plays quite nice games, but it also blunders >horribly from time to time. it's simply not a mature engine (yet, i hope). [Game snipped] 30 games is enough to see a general trend. Muse ranked 163 Elo below Ruffian, and 98 Elo below Delphi, and so very likely they are somewhat stronger. But for other bigshots like the new Pharaon, GLC and AnMon, Muse is of commensurate strength. At least according to one set of measurements. Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws 1 Ruffian 1.0.5 : 2760 101 128 30 75.0 % 2570 30.0 % 2 Delfi 4.5 CIPS : 2695 112 102 30 65.0 % 2587 36.7 % 3 Pharaon v3.1 : 2647 122 105 30 58.3 % 2589 30.0 % 4 Glc 3.034 : 2634 127 102 30 55.0 % 2599 30.0 % 5 Muse0899 : 2597 114 114 30 50.0 % 2597 26.7 % 6 AnMon_550 : 2553 125 122 30 41.7 % 2612 16.7 % 7 Fafis v1.5 : 2477 127 106 30 30.0 % 2624 26.7 % 8 Dragon46Wb : 2437 128 101 30 25.0 % 2628 30.0 %
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.