Author: Dann Corbit
Date: 16:32:25 10/25/04
Go up one level in this thread
On October 25, 2004 at 19:27:25, Dann Corbit wrote: >On October 24, 2004 at 16:53:41, martin fierz wrote: > >>On October 24, 2004 at 16:42:32, Dann Corbit wrote: >> >>>Not a lot of games so far, and at fast time control. >>>AMD 2.2 GHz with 256 MB ram/engine on G/10+10 (ponder off): >>> Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws >>>1 Ruffian 1.0.5 : 2759 129 167 21 73.8 % 2579 23.8 % >>>2 Delfi 4.5 CIPS : 2707 138 121 21 66.7 % 2587 38.1 % >>>3 Pharaon v3.1 : 2646 153 128 21 57.1 % 2596 28.6 % >>>4 Glc 3.034 : 2631 158 118 21 54.8 % 2598 33.3 % >>>5 Muse0899 : 2631 158 118 21 54.8 % 2598 33.3 % >>>6 AnMon_550 : 2558 163 153 21 42.9 % 2608 9.5 % >>>7 Fafis v1.5 : 2463 149 132 21 28.6 % 2622 28.6 % >>>8 Dragon46Wb : 2404 146 123 21 21.4 % 2630 33.3 % >>> >>>But a very impressive showing, none the less. >>> >>>The games so far: >>>ftp://cap.connx.com/pub/chess-engines/new-approach/muscles.pgn.bz2 >> >>hi dann, >> >>nice to see that kind of subject header :-) >>but i have tested muse much more thoroughly than you have, and can say with >>certainty that it is NOT an elite engine. based on my results it should have a >>WBEC rating of around 2420. however, i cannot resist posting a game that patrick >>buchmann recorded during his test of muse... now that's what i call nice - not >>just the result, but also because it really played a nice game! >> >>the bottom line: muse sometimes plays quite nice games, but it also blunders >>horribly from time to time. it's simply not a mature engine (yet, i hope). > >[Game snipped] >30 games is enough to see a general trend. >Muse ranked 163 Elo below Ruffian, and 98 Elo below Delphi, and so very likely >they are somewhat stronger. But for other bigshots like the new Pharaon, GLC >and AnMon, Muse is of commensurate strength. At least according to one set of >measurements. > > Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws >1 Ruffian 1.0.5 : 2760 101 128 30 75.0 % 2570 30.0 % >2 Delfi 4.5 CIPS : 2695 112 102 30 65.0 % 2587 36.7 % >3 Pharaon v3.1 : 2647 122 105 30 58.3 % 2589 30.0 % >4 Glc 3.034 : 2634 127 102 30 55.0 % 2599 30.0 % >5 Muse0899 : 2597 114 114 30 50.0 % 2597 26.7 % >6 AnMon_550 : 2553 125 122 30 41.7 % 2612 16.7 % >7 Fafis v1.5 : 2477 127 106 30 30.0 % 2624 26.7 % >8 Dragon46Wb : 2437 128 101 30 25.0 % 2628 30.0 % Individual statistics for Muse: 5 Muse0899 : 2597 30 (+ 11,= 8,- 11), 50.0 % Ruffian_105 : 4 (+ 0,= 1,- 3), 12.5 % Delfi : 4 (+ 0,= 2,- 2), 25.0 % Glc3034 : 5 (+ 1,= 1,- 3), 30.0 % Pharaon : 4 (+ 2,= 1,- 1), 62.5 % AnMon_550 : 4 (+ 3,= 0,- 1), 75.0 % Fafis : 4 (+ 2,= 2,- 0), 75.0 % Dragon46Wb : 5 (+ 3,= 1,- 1), 70.0 %
This page took 0 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.