Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: wrong solution from chess programs ?

Author: phili_ppe

Date: 06:22:21 04/29/03


Problem from Bruno Fargette, dedicated to Camil Seneca.
from book : "150 problemes d'echecs" by Camil Seneca.

Without the rook at d6 the sole move of black would be Bxf2 then Nxf2 mate.

Try number 1
1. Qb1 ?   Rd2+ !	2. Kxd2 ? stalemate
		2. Kb3	Rd1 !	3. Kb2	Rd2+ !	4. Ka1	Rd1 !! and White is in zugzwang

So the goal is to reach the same position ***with black to move***

Try number 2
1. Kb2 ?	Rg6 !	2. Ka1	Rxg4	3. Qb1	Rxa4+	4. Kb2	Rb4+	5. ... Rxb1 and Black wins

Try number 3
1. Qe4 ?	Rb6 ! and the white king cannot move to a1

SOLUTION  (I do not give variations because there are too many in my book) of
the author :

1. Qb3 !!	Rd7   2. Kb2 !   Rd8   3. Ka1 !   Rd7 !   4. Qc2 !   Rd1+   5. Qb1 !
Rf1 (c1)
6. Kb2   Rd1 !   7. Qc1 !   Rf1   8. Kc2 !   Re1   9. Nxe1 !   Bxf2   10. Nxf2+
 Kg1   11. Ned3 #

This is the theme of the reciprocical zugzwang

Note : the 2 first moves are wait moves.

*** Remark about programs solvers or infinite analysis ***
none of them (Yace, SOS, ChestUci, Crafty) found the solution. They announce
mate in 10 with 1. Qe4   Rb6.
Here what I did : I played these 2 half moves (so it must be now a mate in 9,
right ?). I used Ruffian (as white) in infinite analysis.
When Ruffian searched up to 22 plies, it did not announce any mate, just a
decisive advantage for white.
So I would like to have a absolute opinion about this problem.

Thank you.

8/1Q6/3r4/p7/P5N1/5NPp/2K2Ppr/6bk w - - bm Qb3



This page took 0 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.