Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Top Programs Are at least IM strenght, Probably Better. No Doubt Anymore

Author: Enrique Irazoqui

Date: 08:16:59 05/17/00

Go up one level in this thread


On May 17, 2000 at 11:07:03, Fernando Villegas wrote:

>Hi:
>That best programs are IM strenght is not a novelty. I think I have seen many
>post by Bob saying that, but in any case if a shadow of a doubt still existed,
>the tournament in Holland has given another proof of it. Now IM lose
>systematically to best programs or get a draw or win just once in a while. Now
>an IM winning a top program IS the new. Respect GM, that's another history as
>much as the "GM" expression encloses a very wide category. There are worlds of
>difference between a normal GM and one of the top ten or one of the top five.
>Seems like differences between players get bigger the highest his capacities.
>Between a 1600 and a 1500 elo player there is not really a big gap, but between
>a 2500 and a 2600 there are parsecs of distance. So the discussion should be:
>which kind of GM top programs already are or are near to be? My guess: they are
>or near to be member of the pack of low level GM's. Another guess: they will be
>top 50 GM's class in 5 years at most. And ten top in 10 years, excepto if
>something unexpected happens, like the fall of an asteroid on Earth.
>Fernando

If Fritz draws with van der Wiel, it will get a TPR > 2600 and a GM norm, even
without counting the 2 forfeits of Bosboom and van der Sterren. So a PC program
scored like a grand master, but don't you tell me that plays like one. I seem to
have a semantic problem: the word "master" doesn't come to my mind when I see
how programs (not only Fritz but all of them) play against the van Welys and
Grootens; boom-boom chess may score well, but "master" (mastering the game of
chess) it is not.

Enrique




This page took 0.01 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.