Author: Matthias Gemuh
Date: 10:15:04 07/18/05
Go up one level in this thread
On July 18, 2005 at 09:52:56, Reinhard Scharnagl wrote: >On July 18, 2005 at 09:08:37, Matthias Gemuh wrote: > >>I hope you realize one of your main mistakes concerning Chess960. >>Stefan (SMK) has released a fully functional FRC GUI, so programmers will write >>engines for it. You have released a beta version of Smirf GUI. >>A beta version is fine, but why make it time-limited ? Many will not install it >>for that reason. So very few programmers will side with you against Shredder. >>I am sure even you would not start developing an engine for some time-limited > >Hi Matthias, > >as far as you see Shredder as a stand alone application you might be right. >But it is entering a set of existing definitions and applications also covering >Chess960. > >PGN e.g. demands to a unique encoding of a game thus also for FEN. But Shredders >way to encode positions into FEN depends on the view of its engine. It is >different when created from its Chess960 or its normal view, if encoding >positions, having only castling rights related to traditional K-R placements. >Made proposals for compromising concerning FEN have been refuted all. > >Also it is not true, that a fully compatible UCI extension has not been >possible. I have published a text, how to do this. But this document has had >the goal to sweep away that argument for to use different FEN encodings. Which >way SMK would take to extend his UCI protokoll is far less important compared to >the need to keep compatibility to FEN and existing applications, databases and >PGN viewers already enabled for Chess960. > >SMIRF beta could be tested by everyone. Those who are more interested could >request a time limited key. But even without such a key, most functions will >work and could be tested. It is usual to have shareware enriched with some >nagging details, such is live. > Hi Reinhard, as long as there is no standard nagless GUI supporting your ideas, the ideas will not become standard. Programmers will follow SMK and existing applications will be modified to comply with SMK. Nagless standard GUIs set standards. Best, Matthias.
This page took 0.01 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.