Computer Chess Club Archives

Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question

Author: Jonas Cohonas

Date: 05:56:27 04/15/02

On April 15, 2002 at 08:17:04, Claudio A. Amorim wrote:

>So, are these the programs supposed to play at a 2700 level? Sure, they win many
>games against strong humans, but... Where is their chess competency? Shredder´s
>errors against Smirin were so elementary that they would not fit well in a
>strong club player´s blitz game.

Let's not go crazy over ONE game! we need to ask these questions after the
match, also you can not say "So, are these the programs supposed to play at a
2700 level?" when this is a games based on one programs performance!
Other than that i agree, it was not pretty...

Regards
Jonas

Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Ratko V Tomic 09:07:46 04/15/02
- Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Gian-Carlo Pascutto 09:14:40 04/15/02
  - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Ratko V Tomic 11:00:39 04/15/02
Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 08:52:41 04/15/02
- Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Peter McKenzie 12:27:20 04/15/02
- Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Chris Carson 09:49:59 04/15/02
  - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 10:27:06 04/15/02
    - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question, possible answer...a bug ! Otello Gnaramori 10:37:06 04/15/02
      - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question, possible answer...a bug ! martin fierz 12:51:30 04/15/02
      - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question, possible answer...a bug ! Robert Hyatt 12:02:09 04/15/02
      - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question, possible answer...a bug ! Gian-Carlo Pascutto 10:43:32 04/15/02
    - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Mark Young 10:29:56 04/15/02
      - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Roy Eassa 10:41:58 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Mark Young 11:40:49 04/15/02
  - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Mark Young 09:52:33 04/15/02
    - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Roy Eassa 10:48:29 04/15/02
      - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Uri Blass 12:22:49 04/15/02
      - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Mark Young 11:49:45 04/15/02
    - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Chris Carson 09:56:21 04/15/02
      - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Jeremiah Penery 16:13:03 04/15/02
      - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Mark Young 10:03:42 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 10:28:45 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Mark Young 10:32:46 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Chris Carson 10:20:19 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Mark Young 10:26:08 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Roy Eassa 10:51:36 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Joe McCarro 11:41:59 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Terry McCracken 11:55:06 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Mark Young 12:00:38 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Terry McCracken 12:09:46 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Otello Gnaramori 14:21:39 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Terry McCracken 15:18:17 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Vine Smith 21:55:45 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Roy Eassa 07:36:32 04/16/02
- Ivanchuk has played worse.!? Mark Young 09:40:09 04/15/02
  - Re: Ivanchuk has played worse.!? Roy Eassa 10:23:54 04/15/02
    - Re: Ivanchuk has played worse.!? Robert Hyatt 10:30:07 04/15/02
      - Re: Ivanchuk has played worse.!? Roy Eassa 10:38:56 04/15/02
        
        Re: Ivanchuk has played worse.!? Robert Hyatt 12:04:10 04/15/02
        
        Re: Ivanchuk has played worse.!? Terry McCracken 12:14:10 04/15/02
- Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Mark Young 09:24:08 04/15/02
  - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Roy Eassa 10:14:24 04/15/02
    - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Mark Young 10:21:41 04/15/02
      - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Roy Eassa 10:35:26 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Otello Gnaramori 11:10:30 04/15/02
  - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 09:29:47 04/15/02
    - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Uri Blass 09:46:19 04/15/02
      - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 10:31:37 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Amir Ban 15:24:44 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 19:54:31 04/15/02
        
        : ) NT Mark Young 16:07:30 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Mark Young 11:30:58 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 12:06:47 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Mark Young 13:24:36 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 21:09:11 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Otello Gnaramori 11:17:15 04/15/02
    - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Gian-Carlo Pascutto 09:33:44 04/15/02
      - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 10:32:03 04/15/02
- Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Uri Blass 09:08:05 04/15/02
  - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 09:30:35 04/15/02
Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Jorge Pichard 07:02:48 04/15/02
- Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 08:53:24 04/15/02
  - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Uri Blass 09:13:37 04/15/02
    - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Sandro Necchi 22:53:45 04/15/02
    - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 09:32:00 04/15/02
      - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Otello Gnaramori 11:21:52 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 12:07:44 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Otello Gnaramori 13:56:53 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Terry McCracken 14:20:00 04/15/02
        
        Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Robert Hyatt 11:46:40 04/16/02
    - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Daniel Clausen 09:19:40 04/15/02
    - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Gian-Carlo Pascutto 09:16:38 04/15/02
      - Re: Smirin vs. Shredder - a question Claudio A. Amorim 07:21:00 04/16/02

This page took 0.02 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.