Computer Chess Club Archives


Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Better poll question on DB

Author: Robert Hyatt

Date: 05:13:32 04/23/98

Go up one level in this thread


On April 22, 1998 at 23:56:17, Don Gaetke wrote:

>
>On April 22, 1998 at 22:10:34, Joe McCarron wrote:
>
>>I wonder what computer and software will be the first Chess World
>>Champion.  Does anyone want to venture a guess when that will be?
>>Evidently IBM has no interest in trying to attain the title for deep
>>blue.
>>
>>in response to your post If we had better data on how well micros do
>>against GM's, then the answer to the current poll question would provide
>>the answer to your poll question.
>>
>>It is beyond my unserstandign why we don't have better information on
>>how well these computers do against GM's.  I mean we all know IBM was
>>afraid to play Deep blue against GM's more regularly but these other
>>software programs would seem to jump at the chance to butt heads with
>>GM's.  What is the hold up?
>
>In DBll's case as with the previous programs DB,DTll, and DT, there has
>always been a strong need to keep things "hush, hush", in order to have
>the greatest chance to prove the point that IBM had something unique
>among computers.  It was not advantageous to disclose any performance
>than was absolutely neccessary.
>
>It may yet be that the micro's will threaten the esteem of IBM's  not so
> minor accomplishment.  After all if a PC can beat any top 5 player in
>the world in a real match, then it takes away from IBM's SuperComputing
>achievement in the eyes of the general public.
>
>Don
>
>P.S. CCC is such a breath of fresh air.  :-)



A couple of points:  (1) Until the "IBM" days, information about the
internals was readily available.  A chapter of a book here, a journal
article there...  chiptest/deep thought/deep thought 2 and so forth were
well written-up.  (2) today, there's little chance of a micro beating a
top-5 GM in a match.  It is unlikely in a single game, unless the match
is long enough (and I'm *not* talking about blitz games, there they have
a chance)..



This page took 0.01 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.